great review Andy.. that's exactly how I felt with the movie. Looks great, but nothing else is going for it. The narration got really on my nerves...

Thanks Roman. I'll be surprised, years from now, if people are still watching SIN CITY and judging it as a "great", four-star caliber film...outside of comic book aficionados, of course. I was quite frankly shocked by some of the reviews the movie received.

AndyDursin wrote:Thanks Roman. I'll be surprised, years from now, if people are still watching SIN CITY and judging it as a "great", four-star caliber film...outside of comic book aficionados, of course. I was quite frankly shocked by some of the reviews the movie received.

Me, too. It's all visuals, not much else.