Posted: Tue Jul 13, 2010 12:26 am
Now, I'm not saying this is some sort of misunderstood classic or something, but the critical backlash against it is WILDLY overblown, mainly for three reasons:
1.) M. Night Shyamalan is coming off a string of movies that have ranged from disappointing (Signs, The Village) to soul-scarringly terrible (Lady In The Water, The Happening), and everyone wanted to be first in sharpening their blurb-worthy poison pen barbs.
2.) The animated series is so beloved by its many fans that any deviation from the show was destined to ruffle a lot of feathers, from the weird, pointless name mispronounciations to the whole "racebending" controversy to the horrible decision to compress 20 episodes' worth of densely-layered storytelling into ninety-five minutes of screentime. Now, these elements bugged me as well, but there are countless examples of poor adaptations of good books/TV shows/stage plays/what have you, so why this particular film is getting singled out for so much venom is perplexing.
3.) The decision to do a poor, quickie conversion to 3D, which is a trend that many critics and movegoers are getting deeply sick of, and thus The Last Airbender got the brunt of pent-up criticism for just being the most recent example of this egregious trend.
Honestly, had Last Airbender been an original screenplay, had it not been directed by one of the most widely disliked filmmakers working today not named Michael Bay, and had it been presented only in 2D, I doubt the Tomatometer rating would have dipped much below the mid-40s at the lowest. I mean, the Twilight movies are critical whipping boys, and the latest one only got a modest spanking with a ranking in the mid-50s (and those movies are legitimately terrible). Last Airbender is not one of the worst movies of all time, it'll just be remembered (if at all) as one of dozens of would-be franchise-starters that never made it past their first installments (remember Lemony Snicket? The Golden Compass? Percy Jackson?). I was disappointed with the film, but it's not going to haunt my nightmares the way films like Domino, Seed Of Chucky and Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen have.
1.) M. Night Shyamalan is coming off a string of movies that have ranged from disappointing (Signs, The Village) to soul-scarringly terrible (Lady In The Water, The Happening), and everyone wanted to be first in sharpening their blurb-worthy poison pen barbs.
2.) The animated series is so beloved by its many fans that any deviation from the show was destined to ruffle a lot of feathers, from the weird, pointless name mispronounciations to the whole "racebending" controversy to the horrible decision to compress 20 episodes' worth of densely-layered storytelling into ninety-five minutes of screentime. Now, these elements bugged me as well, but there are countless examples of poor adaptations of good books/TV shows/stage plays/what have you, so why this particular film is getting singled out for so much venom is perplexing.
3.) The decision to do a poor, quickie conversion to 3D, which is a trend that many critics and movegoers are getting deeply sick of, and thus The Last Airbender got the brunt of pent-up criticism for just being the most recent example of this egregious trend.
Honestly, had Last Airbender been an original screenplay, had it not been directed by one of the most widely disliked filmmakers working today not named Michael Bay, and had it been presented only in 2D, I doubt the Tomatometer rating would have dipped much below the mid-40s at the lowest. I mean, the Twilight movies are critical whipping boys, and the latest one only got a modest spanking with a ranking in the mid-50s (and those movies are legitimately terrible). Last Airbender is not one of the worst movies of all time, it'll just be remembered (if at all) as one of dozens of would-be franchise-starters that never made it past their first installments (remember Lemony Snicket? The Golden Compass? Percy Jackson?). I was disappointed with the film, but it's not going to haunt my nightmares the way films like Domino, Seed Of Chucky and Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen have.