"Hickory-dickory, Doc! Cain has picked his lock!"
-
Raising Cain: Recut (1992/2016): 8.5/10
Brian De Palma's looney, self-referential 1992 thriller -- chockablock with split personalities, adultery subplots that go nowhere, surreal dream sequences nesting inside each other like Matryoshka dolls, and a particularly bent series of performances by John Lithgow in multiple roles -- is finally restored to a close approximation of the director's original intent in this dandy new version by Peet Gelderblom, who reconstructed the film online using the original screenplay as a guideline and whose work so impressed De Palma that the director lobbied to have it included on the new Blu-Ray release from Scream Factory. Re-ordering the scenes now makes the film's storytelling perspective shift radically...now instead of opening with Lithgow's character and immediately setting up the purple thriller aspects of the storyline, we begin with Lolita Davidovich's romantic storyline, as she hooks up with old flame Steven Bauer, and the film echoes the structure of that Rosetta Stone of De Palma's Hitchcock fetishization,
Psycho (and his own, earlier
Psycho riff,
Dressed To Kill). It makes the film's transformation from pulp harlequin romanticism into the director's suspense stomping grounds all the more jarring and effective. If I were to show this to someone who had never seen it before, this new cut would definitely be the preferred version. Does it transform the film from a studio-marred botch into a new masterpiece? Hardly...the movie still has certain stylistic and narrative flaws (including some awful, expository voiceover narration from Davidovich that De Palma wisely excised when he wrote similar mush for Angie Dickinson during the museum sequence in
Dressed To Kill, but tossed out when the scene worked perfectly well on its own), and if you don't "get" De Palma's heightened, garish playfulness in deconstructing the thriller form, you'll likely find yourself laughing for the wrong reasons. If you
do appreciate the director's nimble mixture of suspense and black comedy as I do, then
Raising Cain is a film worthy of re-discovery, especially in this new version that will almost certainly be my go-to way to watch it from now on (although kudos to Scream for including the studio-imposed theatrical version as well, for historical purposes).