My favorite Bond film remains one of the more serious outings, OHMSS. This is probably why I found Craig so refreshing. I simply don't like when movies become too silly and preposterous. It is the same reason I prefer Raiders to the Indiana Jones sequels.
Some of the Bond movies
are silly. But I still love them. I love the music, the settings, the girls, the humor -- I don't like the Moore movies either on balance
as much as the Connery films, but it's like different kinds of ice cream. No reason you only have to get the same flavor every time. (That said I stay away from the Brosnan flavors!).
It's like anything else in life -- I might be "better off" watching a serious PBS treatment of substance abuse in a Victorian era household, but I'd rather watch LIFEFORCE over that any day.
That said, I watch Bond movies for certain elements -- which Eon has opted to turn their back on over the last couple of movies. As a long time fan I feel alienated, but I realize they're no longer making these films for someone like me.
I'm right with you that OHMSS is right at the top of the Bond series -- but while it's serious, it's also not joyless. I sense no spark in Craig's Bond persona, he's so stiff and mannered and "tough" that it's like he's trying so hard NOT to inject any life, humor, or even sexual charisma into the part.
MGM and the Broccolis obviously looked at THE BOURNE IDENTITY, decided "what's in", and opted to go that route for the Craig films. Tough, violent, an accent on action as opposed to romance, a decided cold, humorless tone. Strip the series of its hallmarks, aim it at the youth market who are into the humorless genre remakes we see nowadays. Visually and otherwise the Craig movies more than were "inspired" by BOURNE.
CASINO was fine for what it was, a serious "restart" to the Bond movies, but QUANTUM OF SOLACE may have easily been the worst film in the entire series -- yes there are other poor Bonds but at least they had some redeeming other qualities to them, like the music or the cast, etc. QUANTUM OF SOLACE had very few redeeming elements. Watching it through a second time it was even worse than I thought the first time around.