Later, rinse, repeat...
-
Happy Death Day (2017): 7.5/10
-
Happy Death Day 2U (2019): 8/10
Tomorrow ALWAYS Dies in today's pair of loopers. In
Happy Death Day, Jessica Rothe plays Theresa "Tree" Gelbman, a college student who, following a blackout drunk session at a frat party, wakes up in the room of Carter Davis (Israel Broussard), nursing a raging headache and not entirely sure if they did the deed or not. She guts her way through her day, only to end up stalked and murdered by a killer wearing the plastic visage of the school's team mascot (a leering, cherubic baby that sort of resembles a sinister Baby Herman). She then wakes up in the same bed, assuming she just had one hell of a booze-induced nightmare, but has a major case of deja vu as events she witnessed "yesterday" (the same smooching students interrupted by the sprinklers going off, the same soused frat member collapsing on the lawn, the same guy she went on one date with emerging from behind a column to ask why she never texted him back). Then, following a few adjustments to her daily routine finds herself murdered in a slightly different way...only to end up in Carter's room yet again. Soon Tree realizes she's been caught in a loop, stuck repeating the same day over and over, and struggling to find out the identity of her killer and hopefully break the chain and see a new day dawn. Oh yeah, and it's her birthday, too.
Director Christopher Landon (working from a clever screenplay by Scott Lobdell) takes as basic a slasher premise imaginable and wrings a great deal of scares and laughs out of the premise, with Tree -- knowing she'll wake up the next day no matter what -- dying over and over in increasingly baroque and elaborate ways as she winnows the suspect pool down. But
does she possess an unlimited lives code, or is she rapidly running out of quarters, not knowing if the next death will be Game Over? Rothe is tremendously charming as she progresses from puzzlement to acceptance to take-charge ass-kicker, and she generates good chemistry with Broussard as the gentlemanly Carter. I do wish the film were a bit bloodier -- a PG-13 slasher, even a comedic one, is not firing on all cylinders -- but it generates a lot of time-displaced fun along the way.
It takes a certain amount of balls to sequelize a movie entirely based around the idea of a series of events on endless repeat, but
Happy Death Day 2U is a happy exception, and even more clever. Landon returns (working from his own screenplay) to direct, and he manages the task of making a sequel that successfully skews into a new genre while still retaining the aspects of the first that worked. After escaping her endless temporal purgatory at the end of the first, Tree is flabbergasted when Carter's roommate Ryan Phan (Phi Vu) -- who kept obnoxiously entering their dorm room to congratulate Carter on the "Fine vagine" he went home with the previous night -- starts complaining he's stuck in his
own time loop...one related to a science experiment he's been tinkering with. When his quantum reactor goes haywire, Tree finds herself not projected back in time, but into another universe entirely, one where she's no longer romantically involved with Carter (he's hooked up with her snooty sorority sister instead)...but her dead mother is still alive. So now Tree is faced with a dilemma...stay in a universe where her still has her mom, or find a way back to the one where she's still with Carter? Oh yeah, and she has to figure out who the masked killer in THIS universe is at the same time. No pressure...!
While the last few years may have sated our collective desire to see movies set inside of "multiverses",
Happy Death Day 2U is even more enjoyable that the first, even if it hews more close to the sci-fi than horror genre (the "masked slasher" aspect seems grafted on, like it
had to be there in order to sell the movie as a sequel). Again Landon has fun staging a variety of humorous death scenarios for Rothe (like power-chugging detergent in a supermarket and doing her best
Fargo impression with a woodchipper). It's also more emotionally resonant than the first, Tree forced to choose between having the mother she lost back or her new boyfriend. Live in the past, or look forward to the future? It's a lot of fun, and it's a shame the film's underperformance at the box office (although it
still grossed over seven times what it cost to make) scuppered a planned third movie. Still, these two offer up plenty of frights and laughs for those who prefer their slasher cinema on the sillier side.